Sunday, April 5, 2026 - Full Slate
AI Picks Board April 5, 2026
Four AI models. 24 official picks across 11 games. Cubs F5 ML the lone 2/4 consensus. Three models on Yankees side.
SEASON: 114-111-20 | -54.45u | 245 Picks Graded
All Lines: ESPN / DraftKings Sportsbook | Posted: April 5, 2026
Updated Standings (Through April 6 Grading, 12 Pending)
1st
Claude
29-24-6
-0.94u
54.7% Win
2nd
Gemini
24-24-4
-14.08u
50.0% Win
3rd
ChatGPT
27-29-6
-18.70u
48.2% Win
4th
Grok
34-34-4
-20.73u
50.0% Win
Lines - April 5, 2026 (Games With AI Action)
| Game | Fav ML | Dog ML | Total | AI Action |
|---|
| PHI @ COL | PHI -175 | COL +144 | 11.5 | Claude (2), Grok |
| MIA @ NYY | NYY -275 | MIA +225 | 8.0 | Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini |
| NYM @ SF | SF -120 | NYM +100 | 7.0 | Claude (2), Grok, ChatGPT |
| LAD @ WSH | LAD -200 | WSH +165 | 8.5 | Claude, Grok |
| SEA @ LAA | SEA -155 | LAA +130 | 8.5 | Claude, Grok |
| PIT vs BAL | PIT -130 | BAL +110 | 8.5 | Claude |
| DET vs STL | DET -139 | STL +119 | 8.0 | Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini |
| CHC @ CLE (Gm 1) | CHC -130 | CLE +110 | 7.5 | Grok, Gemini |
| HOU @ OAK | HOU -126 | OAK +113 | 10.0 | ChatGPT, Grok |
| MIL @ KC | KC -125 | MIL +105 | 7.5 | ChatGPT |
| ATL @ ARI | ATL -110 | ARI -110 | 9.5 | Gemini |
Multi-AI Consensus (Same Exact Market, 2+ Models)
Only one true consensus play where multiple models picked the identical market. Sorted by vote count and total units.
2/4 Consensus
Cubs F5 ML (Game 1 vs CLE)
Gemini (3u) + Grok (2.5u) = 5.5u committed
2/4
Same Game, Different Markets (Not True Consensus)
NYY side: F5 ML + RL -1.5 + Game U8
Claude F5 ML (1.5u) | ChatGPT -1.5 (2.5u) | Gemini U8 (2u)
3/4
DET/STL Under direction
ChatGPT U8 (1.5u) | Gemini F5 U4 (1u) | vs Claude O8 (0.5u)
2v1
Picks With Opposing Views
Games where AI models are on opposite sides of the total or conflicting directions.
DET vs STL - Total 8.0 Conflict
UNDER: ChatGPT Under 8 (1.5u) + Gemini F5 Under 4 (1u)2 votes
OVER: Claude Over 8 (0.5u) Conditional: if total 9 or lower1 vote
Current total is 8.0, so Claude's condition is met. Two models lean under vs one over. Gemini's F5 Under 4 is a different market (first half only) but aligns with the under side.
NYM @ SF - Mixed Directions Mixed
GAME UNDER: Grok Under 7 (2.5u)1 vote
NYM TT OVER: Claude NYM team total Over (1.5u)1 vote
Game Under 7 could conflict with NYM team total Over depending on the number. Claude also has SF TT Under (1u) which aligns with the low-scoring thesis. ChatGPT has NYM ML (2u), a separate win/lose bet. Four different markets on the same game.
Individual AI Boards
Claude
9 Picks | 4-4-1 (-2.18u) | Season: 29-24-6-0.94u YTD
Phillies F5 ML
PHI F5 @ COL | PHI -175 full game
Yankees F5 ML
NYY F5 vs MIA | NYY -275 full game
Mets Team Total Over
NYM TT Over @ SF | Total 7.0
Phillies ML
PHI -175 @ COL | Current qualifies
LAD/WSH Over 8.5
O 8.5 | LAD @ WSH
SEA/LAA Under 8.5
U 8.5 | SEA @ LAA
Giants Team Total Under
SF TT Under | NYM @ SF | Total 7.0
PIT/BAL Under 8.5
U 8.5 | PIT vs BAL
DET/STL Over 8
O 8.0 | DET vs STL
April 5 graded: 4-4-1 (-2.18u). Phillies F5 and full game ML both lost at Coors. Yankees F5 cashed, as did NYM TT Over and LAD/WSH Over. SF TT Under hit. SEA/LAA Under and PIT/BAL Under missed. DET/STL Over pushed on 8. Season: 29-24-6 (-0.94u).
Grok
6 Picks | 1-3-2 (-5.83u) | Season: 34-34-4-20.73u YTD
Dodgers F5 ML
LAD F5 @ WSH | LAD -200 full game
NYM/SF Under 7
U 7.0 | NYM @ SF
Cubs F5 ML (Game 1)
CHC F5 @ CLE Gm 1 | CHC -130 full
Mariners F5 -0.5
SEA F5 -0.5 @ LAA | SEA -155 full
PHI/COL Over 11.5
O 11.5 | PHI @ COL (Coors)
Astros Team Total Over 5
HOU TT O5 @ OAK | Total 10.0
April 5 graded: 1-3-2 (-5.83u). Rough day. Dodgers F5 ML (3u top play) lost. NYM/SF Under 7 and Cubs F5 ML both pushed. SEA F5 -0.5 and PHI/COL Over 11.5 lost. Only win was HOU TT Over 5. Season: 34-34-4 (-20.73u).
ChatGPT
5 Picks | 2-2-1 (-2.35u) | Season: 27-29-6-18.70u YTD
Astros F5 ML
HOU F5 -127 @ OAK
Yankees -1.5
NYY -1.5 (-133) vs MIA
DET/STL Under 8
U 8.0 (-118) | DET vs STL
April 5 graded: 2-2-1 (-2.35u). Both 2.5u top plays lost (HOU F5 ML and NYY -1.5). Brewers ML and Mets ML cashed as underdogs. DET/STL Under 8 pushed. Season: 27-29-6 (-18.70u).
Gemini
4 Picks | 1-2-1 (-1.90u) | Season: 24-24-4-14.08u YTD
Cubs F5 ML (Game 1)
CHC F5 @ CLE Gm 1 | CHC -130 full
Braves Team Total Over 4.5
ATL TT O4.5 @ ARI | Total 9.5
MIA/NYY Under 8
U 8.0 | MIA @ NYY
DET/STL F5 Under 4
F5 U 4.0 | DET vs STL
April 5 graded: 1-2-1 (-1.90u). Cubs F5 ML (3u top play) pushed. ATL TT Over 4.5 cashed as the lone win. MIA/NYY Under 8 and DET/STL F5 Under 4 both lost. Season: 24-24-4 (-14.08u).
Board Notes
Only one true consensus: Cubs F5 ML in Game 1 of the CHC/CLE doubleheader is the sole 2/4 identical-market agreement (Grok 2.5u + Gemini 3u = 5.5u). This is a light consensus day.
Three models on the Yankees: Claude (F5 ML 1.5u), ChatGPT (run line -1.5, 2.5u), and Gemini (game Under 8, 2u) all touch NYY/MIA but from completely different angles. Not true consensus since the markets are different, but notable directional agreement favoring a dominant Yankees performance.
DET/STL split: ChatGPT takes the game Under 8 (1.5u) and Gemini takes F5 Under 4 (1u), while Claude goes the other way with game Over 8 (0.5u conditional). Two-to-one lean toward the under side.
NYM/SF four-way split: Four different plays from three models on the same game. Grok wants game Under 7 (2.5u). Claude wants NYM TT Over + SF TT Under. ChatGPT wants Mets ML. Each is a distinct market with distinct logic.
Claude's conditional plays: Two plays have conditions. PHI ML requires -240 or better (currently -175, well within range). DET/STL Over requires total of 9 or lower (currently 8.0, condition met). Both conditions are satisfied as of posting.
Grok's top play: Dodgers F5 ML at 3 units is the single biggest play on the board. Roki Sasaki on the mound in Washington is the angle.
PHI/COL total note: Grok's card listed Over 11 but the current line is 11.5. Posted at the current number. Line may have moved since Grok's card was generated.
